On 25 July 1904, a day after the caravan rode into Paris, Henri Desgrange wrote in L’Auto the bitterest sentence of his life: the Tour de France was over, and its second edition, he feared, would have been its last. He wasn't talking about the day. He was talking about the whole race. In barely twenty-two days, the invention that a year earlier had saved his newspaper from bankruptcy had slipped out of his hands: night-time ambushes, nails scattered by the handful, riders stoned and, according to rumours already sweeping France, more than one cyclist who had done part of the route sitting on a train.

Five months later, the winner was no longer the winner. Nor were the second, third or fourth. The jersey —there was no yellow yet, that would come in 1919— ended up on the back of a nineteen-year-old who had crossed the line in fifth place and who is still the youngest winner in Tour history.
A race that started at midnight
The 1904 Tour was held between 2 and 24 July and repeated the 1903 route almost point for point: six stages and 2,428 kilometres split into six colossal bites. The first, from Montgeron to Lyon, was 467 kilometres long. The last, from Nantes to Paris, 471. Between stages there were several rest days, because otherwise it would simply have been impossible.
Stages started at night so that riders would reach the finish in daylight, which meant much of the race was ridden in the dark, on unpaved roads, without team cars and with no help other than what you could carry: the rules banned mechanical assistance and even receiving food outside the checkpoints. The darkness also had a side effect nobody had foreseen: nobody could see anything. Not the judges, not the journalists, not the cyclists themselves.
The ambush on the Col de la République
Disaster struck on the second stage, Lyon–Marseille, with a midnight start. Near Saint-Étienne, local rider Antoine Fauré went through in the lead and some two hundred locals decided to help him in their own way: they blocked the road so nobody could follow him. What came next wasn't a protest, it was a beating. Maurice Garin, the reigning winner, injured a hand. The Italian Giovanni Gerbi was left unconscious in the ditch with several broken fingers and had to abandon. The commissaires only managed to disperse the crowd by firing into the air.
A few kilometres further on, someone had strewn the road with nails and broken glass. Fauré crested the Col de la République in the lead, of course. And on reaching Marseille, the riders demanded en bloc that the stage be annulled: they had been stopped again by a group of cyclists not in the race, Garin had been struck on the arm and rode in steering with one hand. At the last checkpoint there was such confusion that the arrival times weren't even recorded properly.
Nîmes: stones, barricades and a broken bicycle
The third stage passed near the home of Ferdinand Payan, a rider thrown out days earlier for receiving illegal help. His neighbours took it as a personal affront. In Nîmes they put up barricades and stoned the peloton. Several riders were injured and César Garin —Maurice's brother— had his bike smashed: he lost a quarter of an hour looking for another. Further on, nails and glass again; this time the riders crossed the stretch walking beside their bikes.
Sabotage was so routine that on the fifth stage Henri Cornet rode the last forty kilometres with both tyres flat, because repairing them with help was forbidden. And while the public was up to its tricks, the riders were up to theirs: tows from cars, friendly cyclists pulling them along, rests in a car in the shade and, the cardinal sin, train journeys. Nine riders were excluded during the race itself.
The verdict that took five months
At the finish in Paris, the classification said what everyone expected: Maurice Garin first, in 93h 06′ 24″, followed by Lucien Pothier at 6′ 28″, César Garin at 1h 51′ and Hippolyte Aucouturier —winner of four of the six stages— at 2h 52′. Desgrange, who had penalised whoever he saw fit, considered the race closed.
The Union Vélocipédique de France did not. Following complaints from other riders it opened an investigation, heard dozens of witnesses and in December 1904 published a devastating ruling: the top four overall and all the stage winners were disqualified, twelve riders in all. The penalties reached twenty-nine cyclists. Ten were suspended for a year, Maurice Garin for two, and two others were banned for life. Of the twenty-seven who had finished the Tour, only fifteen kept their place.
And here's the most extraordinary part: the specific reasons for each penalty were never made public. The letters and files behind the ruling were kept in the Tour's archives and lost in 1940, when the documents were evacuated south to escape the German invasion. They never turned up again. We know there was cheating and we know who paid for it, but the case file of cycling's founding scandal is, literally, a vanished archive.
A nineteen-year-old champion
The beneficiary was Henri Cornet, fifth on the road, who at nineteen became the youngest winner in Tour history. The record still stands more than a century later and is one of those unlikely ever to be broken. Cornet was no saint either: during the race he'd been reprimanded for letting himself be towed by a car. But his offence was considered minor and the title was his.
He never came close to anything like it again: he rode the Tour seven more times without getting near the podium. Maurice Garin, on the other hand, maintained until the end of his days that he was the rightful winner of 1904, although historian Les Woodland reported that he once confessed to a friend that he had indeed cheated. That Tour, incidentally, also set the opposite record: Henri Paret finished it aged fifty and is still the oldest rider ever to take part.
The Tour de France is over, and I very much fear its second edition will have been its last. It has died of its own success, of the blind passions it has unleashed.
Henri Desgrange, in L’Auto, July 1904
What saved the Tour
Desgrange wasn't just furious with the cheats: he was outraged that the UVF had judged his race after he had already handed out penalties as he saw fit. There was a bitter exchange of letters and a real threat of permanent cancellation. It was the moment when the Tour came closest to disappearing forever.
In the end he changed his mind, but with conditions. In 1905 the Tour reinvented itself: shorter and more numerous stages, daytime starts and, above all, a points classification instead of one based on time, designed precisely so that hopping on a train would no longer pay. It worked. The points system lasted until 1912 and, by then, the race was untouchable.
There's an uncomfortable and very topical lesson: cycling didn't lose its innocence in the nineties or the eighties. It lost it in its second year of life, when it was still raced at night on single-gear bikes. Everything that came later —the rules, the controls, the commissaires on motorbikes— was born of that summer. If you like objects that hold these stories, take a look at our collection: every piece is a fragment of a race that learned to police itself through scandal after scandal.
Keep reading:
→ The first Tour de France (1903) and the newspaper L’Auto
→ The years of the Tour for national teams (1930-1961)
→ The Tourmalet and the phrase that founded the Pyrenean myth
→ The 1998 Tour: the Festina affair and the summer that changed cycling
What’s in the musette
Take home a piece of this story
- Book#ADBooks on the history of the Tourthe best way to follow the thread from 1903 to today.See on Amazon →
- For the wall#ADVintage Tour postersreproductions from the years when cycling was advertised by hand.See on Amazon →
- Bidon#ADClassic aluminium bidonsthe type of bidon riders carried on those 400-kilometre stages.See on Amazon →
- Cap#ADRetro cotton capscycling's cheapest and most recognisable garment.See on Amazon →
Between us: some links are Amazon affiliate links. If you buy something through them, it doesn't cost you a cent more and it helps this little cycling corner keep rolling. Thank you! #ad
Source: historical archive of the Tour de France (Amaury Sport Organisation), press archive of Le Petit Journal and Le Petit Parisien (Gallica, July 1904), Bill and Carol McGann, The Story of the Tour de France 1903-1964, and Christopher S. Thompson, The Tour de France: A Cultural History. Original illustrations by El álbum del pelotón.